This is possibly one of the newest roles in modern football. In fact, due to tactics and the way Premiership clubs play, there are not many holding midfielders that we can actually shortlisted. However, we voted the Top 5 EPL holding midfielders as below.

1. Claude Makelele (Chelsea)
Claude Makelele is the original holding midfielder. He is so effective at this role to the extent that the position he plays is occasionally referred to as “The Makelele Role”.
Since other holding midfielders also get forward and take shots, Makelele, on the other hand, takes the role to the extreme by taking very few shots (he has attempted less than five shots on goal over the last three years), keeping his passes short and safe, and almost never moving into attacking third of the pitch.
He is hailed as the best holding midfielders in the world, and in September 2005, he was selected as a member of World XI at the FIFPro awards.

2. Mohamed Sissoko (Liverpool)
A tough tackling defensive midfield player that is often campared to Patrick Vieira due to similar high energy levels and tendency to make hard tackles.
Powerfully built with good athleticism, he plays a high tempo game that will inject drive into Liverpool’s midfield and provide balance to the more attacking players. In the recent Champions League game against Barcelona, he was so influential that he was awarded Man of the Match by Uefa.

3. Gilberto Silva (Arsenal)
Is often called ‘the invisible wall’, he position himself between two centre backs and the rest of midfield, breaking up opposition attacks before they gather momentum.
His style of defending is unlike normal midfield enforcers, rather than tackle a player, he is more likely to shadow them. As a result, he has an unusually clean record for a defensive midfielder (he has gone 45 games or more without recieving a single booking during his Arsenal career).

4. Nicky Butt (Newcastle United)
Nicky Butt career highlights was in evidence in the World Cup 2002, where he was in the starting line-up only due to injury of Steven Gerrard, the first choice midfielder. He was named ‘the best player in the tournament’ by Pele, a compliment to his performance in the unattractive holding role.
While having mixed fortunes since then, this season Nicky Butt has been much more involved and made a few match winning performance which allows the likes of Scott Parker and Emre to attack from midfield.

5. Javier Mascherano (Liverpool)
While having only played seven Premiership games since joining West Ham and Liverpool, Mascherano is widely regarded as a talented young holding midfielder for Argentina, together with his fellow countryman Cambiasso.
Well known for his passing and hard tackling defense, his performance in the World Cup in Germany drew attention from European clubs as he played every minute of every game for Argentina. After joining Liverpool from West Ham, he was highly praised by Rafa Benitez for his match winning performance against Arsenal. He puts another Man of the Match performance away at PSV in the Champions League quarterfinal.
Other accomplished holding midfielders playing today include Gennaro Gattuso (AC Milan), Esteban Cambiasso (Inter Milan), Owen Hargreaves (Bayern Munich), David Albeda (Valencia) and Emerson (Real Madrid).
Why don’t you tell us your choice of other holding midfielders in EPL?
Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Newcastle United, The Top 5 Holding Midfielders in EPLPopularity: 9% [?]